ZoneAsia-Pk: Tsunami version 2.0

March 8, 2013

By Ahsan Waheed
ZoneAsia-Pk

Elections in Pakistan have a terrifying effect. Like a lie detector, it has been known to expose true sentiments, rivalries, morals and ruthless strategies to guarantee victories. It seems to be doing the same with Pakistan’s rising star, PTI. News about disruptive behavior and violence at PTI’s intra party elections has been popping up time and again. While rival politicians preyed on this disorder as proof of PTI’s poor management skills and experience, the civil society questioned the party’s competence in participating in elections and if elected, its ability to lead democratic processes in the country.

It wasn’t long ago when Imran Khan had taken Pakistan by storm, or in his terms, by a “tsunami”. Since then he and his party have been trying to clean the corrupt system and revolutionize democracy. So far they have introduced an economic, educational and industrial policy. They have refused to form alliances with other parties at the risk of compromising their stand against violence, corruption and inequality.

Read more…


PAKISTAN HAS NO ENEMIES

February 15, 2013

By Ahsan Waheed
ZoneAsia-Pk

As of now Pakistan has no enemies. Even those who hate us and want to do us in are not really our enemies. Take India for example—basking in the glow of its many achievements it is gloating as Pakistan stews in its own juices. All it has to do is wait for juicy morsels to be thrown up by Pakistanis themselves so that it can tweak them and splash them all over the world. The recent plethora of whistle blowers is manna from heaven for the Indian media, establishment and politicians so these whistle blowers are encouraged to spew out more and more poison against their own country and they are falling for it in pursuit of their own warped ambitions.

Consider Afghanistan. It can talk publicly about a strategic relationship and need not be an enemy. It encourages the Pakistanis who have joined hands with others to kill other Pakistanis not just in the western border areas but deep in the heart of Pakistan. Now and then they inspire the misguided Pakistanis who think they are struggling for their rights and freedom by killing their brethren who may be of a different sect or by blowing up the people who are their saviors and by damaging precious assets of the State. There are many who then take on the task of stoking the fires and exploiting the vulnerabilities that emerge. It helps that Pakistanis raise their own voices to condemn their own law enforcers.

Consider the US whom many consider an enemy. It’s not– because it doesn’t have to be. By our actions and our confessions and the antics of our despicable whistle blowers and those who give them a stage we are actually confirming the worst fears of the US and the western world. No one needs to do anything and the well funded think tanks all over are going crazy analyzing and projecting what we are telling them about our past and present. No other country talks endlessly about its own corruption the way we do. No one parades sensitive issues the way we do. In no other country are their own countrymen actively involved in assisting others from inside to carry out dastardly terrorist attacks and subversion. We kill our own governors and then eulogize the killers. We set up national heroes making a laughing stock of ourselves. So called analysts and experts think it is macho to dig up dirt on our own institutions and scatter it all over. No sir—the US need not be our enemy.

Take the Taliban-not the ones fighting to free their country of foreign occupation but those who are fighting and killing to get power so that they can impose their rule and their laws on Pakistan Of course they are Pakistanis but with them are free loaders from all over the world as well as from other parts of Pakistan. There are some who have sympathies for them. Others think we should surrender to them or join them or hold talks with them on their terms. Our confusion translates into the world thinking we have a mindset with Lemming like suicide ambitions. We then find others simply setting themselves up in inspirational or funding roles to keep the body counts high all over the country. The Taliban need not be our enemies to get what they want—they can be our friends and achieve their goals. If they want to talk why don’t they declare a cease fire and talk without pre conditions?

The whole world with many Pakistani included are telling us what to do to get our economy right. We are doing the exact opposite of what they are telling us. Mobilize your resources-we do not. Curb your expenditure-we do not. Stabilize your internal security—we do not. Establish the rule of law-we do not. Get your public sector enterprises under control-we do not. Stop subverting your institutions by using discretionary powers and political clout-we do not. Get everyone to do his job-we do not. Elect political LEADERS not people who want authority-we never did-will we now?

The media is having a ball. It is raking in revenues from advertisements. It has developed clout and uses it to pressurize and extract the maximum from every source. It pits whistle blowers against each other and watches them do each other and the country in. It pits political rivals against each other and then sits back and watches the feathers fly as they scream like banshees. It does not do any heavy lifting like policy analysis, counseling, advising or suggesting or informing-much easier to rake up and scatter muck all round. To hell with the country and its image. The joy in the media is from the excellent local and foreign drama serials, movies and fun talk and comedy shows. No wonder more and more people are getting hooked to these and go to the news channels only during ads in their favorite shows.

So do we have enemies? No we do not because we are own worst enemies. Like sheep we see people lined up for meaningless security checks, waiting in queues for CNG in their vehicles, outside government offices to get some flunkeys approval or signature or simply staring into space as they wait for the power to come back on. Yet it is these people-the common folk in the cities and villages- who are keeping the country afloat and functional. From abroad they send hard earned foreign currency and within the country they work and earn and spend and pray for better days. These people are the true friends of this country and it is their resilience that keeps faith alive and the home fires burning. They demonstrate the great potential that this country has. Long live the people and may the enemies within perish.


ZoneAsia-Pk: The Drone Syndrome

January 15, 2013

By Ahsan Waheed
ZoneAsia-Pk

As another drama-queen-potential-savior explores the niche created by lack of justice and bad governance, we ask ourselves questions about this man’s origins and motivations. Qadri’s history is well known. Part of the Musharraff government, in 2006 he left for Canada and acquired a citizenship. Qadri is the co-founder of a social welfare organization ‘Minhaj-ul-Quran’, currently active in educational pursuits with offices in 80 countries at the moment. In 1991 Qadri also became one of the founders of Pakistan Awami Tehreek and got elected as MNA in 2002. Two years later however Qadri resigned in a dramatic fashion. Blaming the status quo, nepotism and corruption for the suffering of the common man, Qadri left the country in 2006 when his plea for reform fell on deaf ears.

23rd December 2012: Qadri pulled off a rally at the Minar-e-Pakistan much bigger than Khan’s tsunami or any other political or social group has. 2 million people turned up. That was enough to place him in the center of the Pakistani political stage. Who are these people supporting him? And where is his funding coming from? More importantly, whose agenda is he pursuing? As news of Qadri’s success spread like wild fire, the power he had became of more significance than his ideology.

Read more…


In search for a national terrorism policy

October 19, 2012

ZoneAsia-Pk

A country can never be fully prepared to meet the challenges that terrorism, be it of any kind or in any shape, brings. In the Information Age, methods and techniques of terrorism are continuously evolving and the danger keeps escalating. Pakistan faces a unique challenge, for it is the battlefield for fighting terrorists which have caused great human losses across the globe. Since 9/11 it has had to deal great pressure from western powers to curb militants who have targeted foreign nationalities and even Pakistanis. With an economy in distress and meager welfare facilities, all of which are plagued with corruption, insecurity and cases of terrorism have stretched thin the allocation of resources. However, policy makers and analysts feel some of this stress can be relieved if Pakistan deals with security crisis in a systemic and organized manner. Twelve years into the War on Terror and Pakistan still lacks a universal narrative on terrorism. The attack on 14 year old Malala Yousafzai on October 9th uncovered the political rifts in the Pakistani government over counter terrorism.

The world hurled its condemnation on the Taliban militants who targeted Malala, an act that symbolizes the existence of an oppressive mindset that violates basic human rights. Pakistani politicians reacted strongly, some calling for the immediate enactment of the North Waziristan Operation to eliminate the militants. MQM expressed great disapproval with Altaf Hussain urging the army to immediately begin the Waziristan operation. Repeated failure of dialogue with the Taliban has convinced him of the need for a military response. Although ANP and MQM do not see eye to eye on all matters, the former’s failure against Taliban in Peshawar caused it to support a military response. The ruling party, PPP, was not far behind in denouncing the attack. Its senior leaders including the PM vowed to root out extremism but they were hoping the Army or the parliament would take the initiate by approving of an operation. However, the Army threw the ball in the government’s court by necessitating its approval for any such action while resistance from opposition parties thwarted a parliamentary endorsement. The government finally decided to play safe by promising that such a decision will be taken if the need arises with the backing of the political and military leadership.

Even though all political parties criticized the attack to some degree or another, some parties chose to disagree with a military reaction against terrorists. The JI and JUI, for instance, urged the government not to misuse this incident to gain some political advantages and support for a military operation. At the same time, various conspiracy theories regarding the role of Malala as a spy and the wider interest of America in exploiting Pakistan sprung up. Significant opposition also came forth from Imran Khan, leader of PTI and the savior of Pakistan according to its rapidly growing supporters. He believed a military action to be premature which if carried out would aggravate the security crisis. Khan suggested a three point strategy: detachment from the American War on Terror, dialogue with the militants and as a last resort, military action. He particularly stressed on the participation of the locals in these decisions so that they did not feel alienated.

PML-N is a step ahead of many parties as they not only differ with other parties but their own members also have conflicting viewpoints. Although they have opposed the government’s plan for a military operation in Waziristan, their leaders haven’t explicitly favored dialogue either. PML-N members claim this to be a political trick to delay elections. Still we have Marvi Memon propagating a forceful response while Zafar Ali Shah, Khurram Dastgir and Saad Rafiq have been open to the option of cooperation as part of a multidimensional approach.

If this wasn’t enough, the matter of a terrorism policy was muddled with pro-Malala and anti-Malala discourses. Phrases like “You are either with the Taliban or against the Taliban” were being used to determines one’s loyalty to the state or the militants. A national terrorism policy cannot be simplified to just the Taliban, the drones or US intervention in Pakistani affairs. In fact they are the constituents of that policy.

A difference in opinion over the Waziristan operation should guide debate and discussion over other issues to eventually reach a state policy against terrorism. This is however only the first part of the process; the policy must then be implemented. Malala’s attack was most unfortunate but when seen in the context of the upcoming elections and worldwide outrage, it may be just the right amount of push needed to ensure that political parties come up with policy agreeable to all and sundry.


India’s Cry Wolf App?

October 14, 2011

By Deepika Jaitley
Area 14/8

‘Rape Capital’ Delhi, sprawling metropolis and epicenter of the Government of India, is also victim to elements of endemic sexual violence. Earlier this year an English local newspaper published statistics under the headline: Shame on Delhi Men. “The dazzling streets of Delhi hide a dark truth,” it said, publishing the results of a poll revealing that 66% of the capital’s women were molested between two and five times last year and that 70% of men “looked the other way” when it happened. What happens when they don’t was amply demonstrated earlier this year when a 55-year-old rickshaw driver in West Delhi was beaten to death for “defending his daughter’s modesty” from a group of drunks.

Cracking down on sexual predators, in what is the most dangerous city for women in India, hasn’t borne much fruit considering Delhi’s stereotypical policeman is a figure of legend, renowned for sloth, corruption, brutality and casual misogyny. To counter pandemic violence charities of all sorts have come to the fore one of which is Whypoll a local charity which has devised a smart phone app “Fight Back” that is to be launched in November this year. Whypoll will function as an SOS alert device — sending out a text message with a GPS location to up to five people, including police, and as a post on Facebook and Twitter. This app will be available to download from the Whypoll website for a small fee and will be supported by a range of smart phones such as Nokia and BlackBerry.

Read Complete Article Here: http://www.area148.com/cms/?p=8148#more-8148


HO HUM

April 5, 2011

By: Salman Azeem
ZoneAsia-Pk

The dictionary explains ‘ho hum’ as being an ‘expression of tediousness or boredom’. Ho Hum, therefore, best describes the state of minds in Pakistan. There was a time several months ago when the media, political aspirants and others created the hype of an imminent change of government. Media debates and writings ranged over various possibilities. Politicians in the opposition ran around trying to forge alliances and hurl derogatory epithets at others. An activist judiciary was seen as the torch bearer of change and the ‘establishment’ was seen as being in support of the judiciary and the secret behind the scenes manipulator. Each new event whether on the streets of Karachi or Baluchistan or in FATA or Punjab was seen as another nail in the governments’ coffin. Lurid details of corruption, mismanagement and cronyism were being shouted from rooftops.

This is no longer the case now. The politicians in the opposition are running around like headless chickens – outwitted and out maneuvered. The media continues its diatribes but these are accepted and no longer make waves or even ripples – they are seen for what they are, ploys for revenue generation from advertisements. The judiciary is independent and going about its business with some cracks visible – no one expects miracles. The establishment has been accepted as having broken from the past and is seen as a bystander with its work cut out. Scams and scandals surface and disappear into investigations and court procedures. Lawlessness is being accepted as kidnappings, murders, random killings, bombings and street rage become a fact of life – not even making headlines any more. Bizarre incidents like the Davis killings and the Taseer-Bhatti murders provoke rage that peters out into despair. The government continues to function and the country gets run somehow. Economic decline, rising prices, increasing poverty and joblessness are topics for discussion because there is nothing else to discuss. Life goes on and the name of the game is acceptance and compromise. No one is excited anymore – not even by the 2013 elections.

No longer is the nation waiting for a savior to come galloping on a white horse. No one is expecting the strategic ally – the US or the much touted Friends of Pakistan to work a miracle in Pakistan. If anything the suspicion about US intentions has reached a crescendo. Reality has kicked in. The reality is that this elected government is going to complete its tenure – its accomplishments are being slowly seen from between all its warts. Political shenanigans are exposing people as never before. No one has so far said anything profound, strategic or visionary – the future looks dreary. There is grudging acceptance of the fact that the country has weathered difficult situations – some of Tsunami strength and held its own. Dire predictions continue to be made but they lack conviction and those making them lack credibility. The ‘establishments’ hands-off policy is being accepted as reality and even the pronouncements by the US fail to create a dent. This is a classic case of a game having been played to the finish leaving everyone exhausted – no one is crying foul and if someone is then there is no listener.

The time has come to move on. The media needs to revamp with meaty futuristic debates. The political scene needs new faces below thinking brains. The US needs to rethink strategy to change its image in public opinion. The ‘establishment’, the bureaucracy and the judiciary need to deliver – to the people. Those in power need to see the snowball that might roll on despair turned into rage to gain size, momentum and power before.


The double standards of the International Cricket Council

March 8, 2011

By Omar Farooque
Area14/8

The cricketing world was taken by surprise when the great Australian leg-spinner Shane Warne predicted a few hours before the crucial World Cup Group ‘A’ fixture between India and England that the match would result in a tie. Warne wrote on his Twitter page: “Looking forward to the game between India and England – should be a cracker, my prediction – a tie!”. To everyone’s surprise the match actually did turn out to be a nail biting tie when England equaled the Indian teams mammoth total of 338 runs, which at one point during the match seemed like an unachievable feat. During the press conference after the match Andrew Strauss, the England Captain jokingly shrugged off Warne’s prediction as a stroke of genius, but former Pakistan fast bowler Sarfraz Nawaz said “Something is definitely up when you start predicting a tie instead of talking about who you think is going to win or lose a match. And especially when such a statement comes from someone as controversial as Shane Warne who, apart from his doping scandals and irresponsible statements in the media, has also been in trouble over being accused of taking money from an Indian bookmaker in return for pitch and weather information.”

In February 2011, the International Cricket Council tribunal had found the Pakistani trio – Salman Butt, Mohammad Asif and Mohammad Amir guilty of corruption. Former captain Butt was handed down a 10-year ban, with five out of the ten years suspended, Asif seven years – two suspended – and the 18 year old prodigy Amir five years. In the past few years, Pakistan has been at the center of attention for anything related to doping scandals, ball-tampering and match-fixing. In recent years Pakistani players have faced stern action on accounts of ball tampering and allegations related to match fixing.

India has been home to the major match-fixing scandals in cricket apart from this latest one involving the Pakistani trio. In 2000, the Delhi police intercepted a conversation between a blacklisted bookie and the South African cricketcaptain Hansie Cronje in which they learnt that Cronje accepted money to throw matches. The South African government refused to allow any of its players to face the Indian investigation unit. A court of inquiry was set up and Cronje admitted to throwing matches. He was immediately banned from all forms of cricket. During the inquiry Cronje also named Saleem Malik (Pakistan), Mohammed Azharuddinand Ajay Jadeja (India) to be part of the match-fixing scam. Malik and Azharuddin were handed down life bans whereas Jadeja was banned for 4 years.

Furthermore, Shane Warne has also been involved in a number of incidents on and off the field in his cricketing career. Out of all the incidents the most famous was his alleged interaction with an Indian Bookmaker. The Indian bookmaker known as “John” in 1994-95 gave money to Australian cricketers Mark Waugh and Shane Warne, in return for pitch and weather information. However, according to the players, they refused to divulge more strategic material, such as team tactics and player selection policies. The matter was initially covered up by the Australian Cricket Board (ACB), which decided that it was sufficient to privately fine the players. The ACB concluded that, since Waugh and Warne had previously accused Pakistani cricket captain Saleem Malik of attempting to bribe them to lose matches, their credibility as witnesses would be damaged if their own involvement with John was publicized. The ACB reported the matter to the International Cricket Council, and there the matter ended.

Adding fuel to the fire, a number of incidents during the England vs. India fixture were of suspicious nature. Both the teams are considered to be very good fielding sides but during the match the fielding was absolutely abysmal. Virendar Sehwag was dropped twice in the first over of the Indian innings and the fielding show put on by the Englishmen later on in the innings was exceptionally bad. Furthermore the crucial stumping chance missed by the England Wicketkeeper Matt Prior was a shocker. Furthermore, Andrew Straus’s during his infamous knock of 158 runs nicked the ball twice which landed in Mahendar Singh Dhoni’s hands but not even a single player from the Indian Outfit appealed. It seemed as if the Indians did not want Strauss to get out. The most surprising incident of the match was when on the last ball of the match England took a single even though they could have tried for a double to win the match. These incidents were either carefully orchestrated or were pure coincidence but despite all these facts the ICC’s Anti Corruption and Security Unit should launch a proper investigation. If Pakistani bowlers bowling no-balls can cause such a big stir in the cricketing world then this was a World-Cup match, where the stakes are at their highest.

Given the colorful past of the cricketer turned commentator Shane Warne it is baffling why a proper inquiry by the ICC has not been initiated up till now. This further augments the suspicion that ICC is biased towards some nations. What if Pakistani commentators Wasim Akram or Rameez Raja had made such a prediction? Would the ICC remain quiet if Pakisani Cricket pundits had made such a prediction? Would Andrew Strauss still shrug it off like a joke?

In a recent interview, another Pakistani Cricketer turned commentator accused the ICC of double standards and said “When our (Pakistan) players are implicated in match-fixing on the smallest of pretext by the authorities of the game, then why has Warne’s prediction about the ‘tie’ not raised any eyebrows in the ICC? To me, these are clear double standards from (ICC chief Haroon) Lorgat and Co. everyone knows that India is the hub of bookies and match-fixers, so we can’t just rule Warne’s comments out as ‘casual remarks’. But since this prediction comes from an Australian player it is declared a stroke of genius.”

Cricket has been scandalized by several gambling and match fixing allegations in recent years and most of these incidents have either happened in India or there have been definite links to Indian bookies. According to the head of the ICC’s anti-corruption unit Paul Condon, cricket is the most bet on sport in the world and fixing is found at every level of the sport and is a significant problem. In light of the current situation, where the integrity of cricket as a sport is at stake, it’s about time that the ICC should let go off its double standards and work on a solution to make cricket a clean and fair sport devoid of any scandals or fixed matches.


Indian Govt stands exposed Reacting to (and Insulting) Supreme Court’s judgment

March 3, 2011

by Thinktank

Reacting to Supreme Court’s judgment of cancelling the controversial appointment of PJ Thomas as Chief Vigilance Commissioner, BJP on Thursday said that the decision has completely exposed government on the issue of corruption.

Coming down heavily on the government BJP spokesperson, Rajiv Pratap Rudy said, “Misgoverance has been proved by apex court’s ruling.”

Addressing the reporters outside the Parliament Rudy also observed that the judgment vindicates Leader of Opposition Sushma Swaraj as well as BJP’s stand.

“Today, in a historic decision, the CVC appointment by the union government has been struck down. This also vindicates the BJP position, more so the position taken by the Leader of Opposition Sushma Swaraj who had opposed the appointment then on the same ground on which the Supreme Court has struck it down,” he said.

Thomas was appointed CVC on September 7 last year. The CVC is selected by a committee made up of the Prime Minister, the Home Minister and the Leader of the Opposition. At a meeting on September 3, 2010, the BJP’s Sushma Swaraj placed on record her objections to Thomas’ candidacy. The government over-ruled her, and Thomas was appointed.

Another BJP leader Ravishankar Prasad said it was a “historic” day for the Rule of Law and that Thomas was tainted from Day one.

Both house of the Parliament were adjourned minutes after the verdict but, surely, the government will have to face a reinvigorated united Opposition, who now seems to be gunning for the Prime Minister as well as the Home Minister.

CPI(M) politburo member Sitaram Yechury said he will take rake the issue in Parliament and the government should answer how was the appointment of Thomas was given a go ahead when his name figured on corruption cases and was also chargesheted.

JD(U) chief Sharad Yadav also hailed the apex court’s decision and said Home Minister P Chidambaram who was part of the selection process should resign on moral grounds.

CPI’s D Raja said the court decision was a “big blow” for the Union Government.



Raids could loosen Suresh Kalmadi’s hold over Pune

December 27, 2010

Imtiaz Jaleel

Pune: Raids that lasted eight hours at his houses in Delhi, Mumbai and Pune didn’t seem to affect Suresh Kalmadi’s holiday cheer.

”I’m not hurt. I told you I wanted to give good Games. After that I’m ready for any investigations. So I am happy they’ve come and gone and they’ve taken whatever they wanted,” said the man who chaired the Organizing Committee of the Commonwealth Games.

His laptop and some hard drivers were among the items collected by the CBI which showed up at his homes early this morning.

While Kalmadi – a politician of considerable experience and acumen – keeps up the bluster, he is increasingly finding himself in a corner with allies in the slim-to-none category.

Even before the Games began, near-daily reports in the media proved the voluptuous and naked corruption that seemed embedded in every aspect of the Games. Virtually every major contract -from broadcast rights to sponsorship deals – seemed infested with financial malevolence. The men in charge of the Games seemed to have signed on dotted lines that, when traced, led to the front doors of their families and friends.

At the closing ceremony for the Games, Kalmadi was booed by a stadium packed with thousands, Sonia Gandhi shook her head when he thanked Rahul Gandhi and her for their support and leadership.

On November 9, 2010, Kalmadi was dropped as Secretary of the Congress Parliamentary party. (Read: Suresh Kalmadi sacked from senior Congress post)

Pune has been his bastion – for 30 years, he has represented the city in the Lok Sabha and Rajya SAbha. His lordship covered not just politics, but the cash-rich automobile industry that’s based here.

Kalmadi ensured that Pune remained unwinnable for Sharad Pawar’s Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), even as the party strengthened its control over the rest of Western Maharashtra.

The raids in Pune today could impact the municipal elections, scheduled in 2012. The NCP knows that it has a soft target now in Kalmadi – and it’s taking aim.

”Definitely it will impact the Congress. The morale of their workers is down. We will see a political change in the municipal elections of 2011,” said NCP spokesperson Ankush Kakde.

The CBI earlier arrested three of Kalmadi’s close aides. Their interrogation – and today’s raids – have nudged Kalmadi into an odd defense . He doesn’t deny any wrongdoing- instead, he opts for safety in numbers, stressing that he could not have acted alone. ”There’s an entire executive board. There’s an Organizing Committee Finance Committee, another finance committee, all the government officers there,” he says.

Absolutely, says the BJP, whose leaders sarcastically suggested today that Kalmadi turn approver and turn in the big fish in the Congress who allegedly benefitted from the crooked deals he struck.

In the run up to the Games, Kalmadi worked hard to project himself as the face of one of India’s largest events – the Games would be unforgettable, he promised repeatedly. The credit for the Games eventually went to officials like Delhi Chief Minister Sheila Dikshit. And Kalmadi is a solitary man now, the unwitting totem of the roughest side of the Games.


Young Russians in search of faith are turning to Islam

December 23, 2010

By Will Englund
Washington Post Foreign Service

ALMETYEVSK, RUSSIA Rustam Sarachev should have had a hangover the first time he set foot in the central mosque here. He had wanted to throw a raucous party the night before, a send-off for himself on his way to Islam. But the guys he was with had mocked him for even thinking about the mosque, and had gone off drinking on their own.


In the Russian heartland, young people are discovering spiritual fulfillment by turning to Islam, the religion of their Tatar ancestors.

So here he was, regretfully clearheaded in the daylight, 500 rubles unspent on vodka and still in his pocket, heading up the steps of the big salmon-colored mosque that dominates one end of this minor oil city east of the Volga.

It was late September 2006, the beginning of Ramadan. As he looks back on it now, he remembers that he wasn’t sure why he had decided to come, or what to expect. He was 17, at loose ends, a self-described hooligan, a troublemaker, starting to get hardened by a life that was heading for the verges of the law, yet still vulnerable to the insults and disdain that seek out young men with no future here.

When he walked through the great double door of the mosque, he was taking his first steps toward joining an intense Islamic revival here in the Muslim heartland of Russia that is drawing particular strength from its young people.

Sarachev was 2 years old when the Soviet Union collapsed, 5 when the first war in Chechnya broke out, 12 on 9/11. His whole life has been an era of cataclysms, of an old world being torn apart, of war against Muslims, at home and abroad. Old identities, old certainties, have proved empty. And now he was joining others here of his own generation who are finding, in religion, an alternate authority. They are joining a global community, and at a time when great passions are stirring that community.

They learn at the mosque that Allah is punishing Iraqis for their heresies. They learn that 9/11 was carried out by American agents, or maybe agents from somewhere else, to provoke a war against Muslims. But they learn, too, that those who want to go and join the fight in Afghanistan, or Pakistan – and young men who aimed to do precisely that have passed through Almetyevsk – are in error. This is not the time. Islam needs them here, in Russia.

Their faith, in any case, is not ignited by politics. If it were, the Russian authorities would have cracked down on the mosque long ago. Sarachev came up those steps, on that day four years ago, not out of anger but in search of a way out of the pointlessness of his own life.

Built in the 1990s with Saudi backing, the mosque makes a strong physical statement. Inside, it features intricate woodwork, handsome red and green carpets and painstakingly assembled blue tile mosaics. On holidays, believers pack its services. During afternoon prayers, as they face to the southwest, toward Mecca, a window to their right might give them glimpses of a glorious pearly pink sky, otherworldly almost, even as the setting sun glints off the five golden domes of the Orthodox church across the way.

“I was shocked,” remembers Sarachev. “I couldn’t understand where I was. There were only young people, all around. They treated me so well. I’d never been welcomed like that before.”

He saw familiar faces. Almas Tikhonov, who had been a big partier and a roughneck, and then had dropped from sight, was there, praying. Sarachev was impressed by the way Almas looked; there was a compelling serenity about him.

In the days that followed, that picture lingered in Sarachev’s mind. He decided to go back to the mosque, and then again, and again. He had to endure the jibes of his old friends, and that was hard – but maybe it stiffened his resolve, too. As he began to see them in a new light, it made it simpler to give up the drinking, the hanging out on street corners, the sneaking off to a village where they could party all night, away from parents’ eyes. Sarachev eventually came to understand that the world is full of devils, and that the duty of a good Muslim is to overcome those devils.

And somewhere here, he knows, though he’s still working it through in his own mind, lies the meaning of jihad. “It’s a struggle against those who don’t believe,” he says. “It’s not a test. Jihad is a war.”

Sarachev is a Tatar. His ancestors converted to Islam in the 9th century, when Tatarstan was a powerful state in its own right. For the past 450 years, the Tatars have lived under Russian domination; proud of their heritage, they consider themselves the natural leaders of Russia’s 30 million Muslims.

But Sarachev’s forebears didn’t practice Islam the way he understands it today. Over a millennium, Tatars had developed a rich and complicated theology, comfortable with rational thought and mindful of the need to coexist with the Christian Russians. In Kazan, Tatarstan’s capital, the religious establishment endeavors to carry on that tradition today.

But Soviet hostility to religion left most Tatars with only a perfunctory sense of their own Muslim inheritance. Growing up, Sarachev remembers, religion meant grandparents and holidays, and little else. Yet even then, just after the collapse of the Soviet Union, Arab proselytizers had come to Tatarstan, and they were preaching a different sort of Islam – starker, simpler, more puritanical. It has taken root here, and it appeals powerfully to young people who, like Sarachev, are drawn to its order and rules, and to its purity.

Slow acceptance

Almetyevsk, a city of 150,000 with no history to speak of – it was founded in 1955 – lies among low brown ridges, a four-hour drive east of Kazan. It’s not material poverty here that drives young Tatars to Islam, because oil and gas have brought prosperity, but a spiritual poverty in a country where every institution, from schools to hospitals to the police, is riddled with cynicism and corruption.

Sarachev’s parents divorced when he was young. His mother works at a pipe factory; Sarachev has a job there now, too, operating a hydraulic press. He still lives at his mother’s apartment.

When he embraced Islam he learned that everyone is born with an inner faith, “and it is the parents who turn a person away from religion.” Not necessarily one’s literal parents, he adds; it could be a metaphor for society. But it’s little wonder that his own mother and father were unhappy with his religious awakening and rejection of the culture they lived in.

“They didn’t understand,” he says. “There were fights and quarrels. But of course they had been very mad at me when I was getting home late and drunk.” So when they saw that that stopped, they started, slowly, to come around. Now, he says, if his mother sees him praying at home, she’ll close the door and won’t interfere. (She adamantly refused to be interviewed for this article.)

This year, for the first time, they gave him the money to buy a sacrificial sheep.

Nov. 16 was the day Muslims honored Ibrahim, who intended to slit his son Ismail’s throat but sacrificed a ram instead. After an early-morning service at the mosque, a large crowd moved outdoors to a parking area for buses. Now it was filled with farmers’ trucks, each carrying a dozen or so restless sheep. Under a damp sky, the chief imam, in a gray hat made from fetal lamb’s skin, presided. With him stood the head of the city administration, the veterinary officer, and plainclothes leaders from the security services.

The sheep – more than 600 of them, each hobbled with three feet tied together – were carried to wooden pallets laid out on the ground, where their jugular veins were slashed. Blood flowed down gutters that ran the length of each pallet. At times a butcher would have to sit on an animal for a minute or more after its head was half severed, as it kicked and heaved.

Then the carcasses were skinned and cut into three equal parts: one for the purchaser, one for his relatives, and one for the poor.

“Those who cut a Muslim into three parts are much worse than those who cut a sheep into three parts,” said the imam, Nail bin Ahmad Sakhibzyanov.

Sarachev went home happy, proud in the profession of his faith. The imam went home happy, too. It was the biggest slaughter yet in Almetyevsk.

Striving for faith

Sakhibzyanov, 53, studied to be an imam in what was then Soviet Uzbekistan. He says he dealt with the KGB agents who infiltrated religious schools in those days by telling them what they wanted to hear. What a man says, he suggests, is not necessarily what’s in his heart.

Today, this is what Sakhibzyanov says: that his goal is to help Tatars regain their traditional religion. Yes, he studied in Saudi Arabia in the 1990s, and yes, the school he runs uses a Saudi curriculum. But naturally he subscribes to the Tatars’ traditional Hanafi branch of Islam, he says; if he didn’t, his school would lose its license. He only wants to help the wayward Tatars, buffeted by centuries of Russian and Soviet rule, find their way.

His opponents in Kazan say his Islam is Hanafi in name only, that it otherwise bears the hallmarks of its Arab – or Salafi – origins. They say its focus on Islamic purity is the flip side of intolerance toward other Muslims, and narrow-minded zeal.

“Almetyevsk is the center of Islamic radicalism in Russia,” says Rafik Mukhametshin, rector of the Russian Islamic University in Kazan. “They’re trying to return to a mythical Islam. And they’re unpredictable because they refuse to learn from history.”

Almetyevsk, he says, is the most dangerous spot in Russia.

And yet part of Islam’s appeal for Sarachev was its promise of simple domestic happiness.

“I had a choice,” he says. “Either the street – alcohol and cigarettes and all that stuff – or a very pleasant atmosphere and pleasant people.”

Now, instead of partying, he plays on an all-Muslim rugby team. He drinks coffee instead of vodka, and where once he danced, now he likes to take walks. The job is just a job, but the pay allows him to spend convivial hours at the banya – the Russian sauna.

His new friends at the mosque have married, and they have jobs and kids and cars. Sarachev’s aim is to live the good, respectable life. He sees Islam as the way to achieve it.

That’s not exactly radical. But he knows, uneasily, that there’s more to his Islam than that. Faith is difficult and much is demanded. Islam has powerful enemies, not only the non-believers who wage war on Muslims but also the devil that lives in everyone. Error is widespread, and Sarachev is keen to avoid it, if he can only be sure how.

Sakhibzyanov tells his followers that the struggle is between the soul and the brain – between faith, in other words, and thought. The Muslim must strive for faith.

If that’s true, his detractors argue, it’s no wonder the imam’s Islam has such a strong appeal for those who learned their values on the street, in the with-us-or-against-us world at the margins of society.

But not every young worshiper here has that background. Guzel Sharipova, 23, was everything as a student that Sarachev was not; she studied chemistry on a full scholarship in Kazan, and graduated with highest honors. It was in Kazan that Islam found her, thanks to an Arab boyfriend. She was living with her great-aunt, Galima Abdullina, a retired schoolteacher, and began asking her about the prayers she recited. Eventually, she put on a veil.

“She was a girl who loved life, and suddenly she became so religious,” says Enzhe Anisimova, Abdullina’s daughter. “We watched her as a baby, and she was so beautiful, and spreading light. Now she’s so serious. Islam is very close to me, but that doesn’t mean that I accept everything. Something in it really attracts Guzel. But what is it? If she has found answers to the questions she was trying to find answers to, maybe that solved something for her.”

Sharipova says, “Everyone has a time to come to Islam.” She draws deep satisfaction from the rules it imposes. That frees up so much. She works now as a chemist – with her brain – but she gives her attention to her soul.

And where Sarachev hopes Islam will bring him modest comforts, Sharipova treasures the way it allows her to discard life’s vanities. “I’m trying to spend time on only necessary things,” she says.

New expectations

Rustam Sarachev came to the mosque knowing almost nothing about Islam. Now he knows that praying to ancestors, or saints, is the worst imaginable sin. He knows that being Muslim is more important than being a Tatar. He knows that the Russian special services don’t like Islam because the alcohol and tobacco Muslims reject are big businesses. He knows those same special services dread the day when all people turn to Islam.

His ancestors, in centuries past, drank beer and mead at weddings and often sought the intercession of their forebears in prayer. Would Sarachev consider them Muslims if he met them today – or devils? In his earnest way, he’s only beginning to deal with the difficult questions. He’s happy that Islam is helping him find the answers.

“Everyone eventually asks, ‘Why am I here? Why will I die? What will happen after I die?’ You gradually start to understand who you are and why you were created.”

It is, he says, to live a pure Muslim’s life. And, through Islam, all is spelled out. “The prophet showed people everything – from how to go to the toilet to how to run a state.” But there’s still so much to get straight in his own mind.

Last year, Sarachev got to know some young men who wanted to pick up guns and go fight abroad. They weren’t from the mosque. He thinks they had taught themselves Islam on the Internet. Sometimes, when they met on the street, they’d start urging him to go off and fight against Americans.

He says he was troubled by it, and as he describes it he still looks troubled by it. He’s struggling to understand even now what’s expected of him by his religion. He went to the mosque and asked the imams for advice.

They explained to him, he says, that these young men were mistaken. “Those people who say they want to fight, they’re like foam on water. There’s a lot of foam, but it’s useless.”

Eventually they went away, he doesn’t know where. Sarachev, yearning to dig deeper into Islam, is still uncertain about jihad, and the fight against devils. “It’s very complicated. I don’t want to be wrong.”

Sakhibzyanov knew about the would-be fighters. All Muslims, he says, know they are part of a larger community that must defend itself. But leaving Tatarstan to fight elsewhere is, he says, the wrong choice. “They are needed here.”

The imam is a savvy navigator in a potentially hostile culture. Islam, he says, is a peaceful religion, violence is a sin and the task for Rustam Sarachev and other young Muslims is to keep studying and deepening their certainty in its purity and oneness. And then more will follow, and then more.


Young Russians in search of faith are turning to Islam

December 23, 2010

By Will Englund
Washington Post Foreign Service

ALMETYEVSK, RUSSIA Rustam Sarachev should have had a hangover the first time he set foot in the central mosque here. He had wanted to throw a raucous party the night before, a send-off for himself on his way to Islam. But the guys he was with had mocked him for even thinking about the mosque, and had gone off drinking on their own.


In the Russian heartland, young people are discovering spiritual fulfillment by turning to Islam, the religion of their Tatar ancestors.

So here he was, regretfully clearheaded in the daylight, 500 rubles unspent on vodka and still in his pocket, heading up the steps of the big salmon-colored mosque that dominates one end of this minor oil city east of the Volga.

It was late September 2006, the beginning of Ramadan. As he looks back on it now, he remembers that he wasn’t sure why he had decided to come, or what to expect. He was 17, at loose ends, a self-described hooligan, a troublemaker, starting to get hardened by a life that was heading for the verges of the law, yet still vulnerable to the insults and disdain that seek out young men with no future here.

When he walked through the great double door of the mosque, he was taking his first steps toward joining an intense Islamic revival here in the Muslim heartland of Russia that is drawing particular strength from its young people.

Sarachev was 2 years old when the Soviet Union collapsed, 5 when the first war in Chechnya broke out, 12 on 9/11. His whole life has been an era of cataclysms, of an old world being torn apart, of war against Muslims, at home and abroad. Old identities, old certainties, have proved empty. And now he was joining others here of his own generation who are finding, in religion, an alternate authority. They are joining a global community, and at a time when great passions are stirring that community.

They learn at the mosque that Allah is punishing Iraqis for their heresies. They learn that 9/11 was carried out by American agents, or maybe agents from somewhere else, to provoke a war against Muslims. But they learn, too, that those who want to go and join the fight in Afghanistan, or Pakistan – and young men who aimed to do precisely that have passed through Almetyevsk – are in error. This is not the time. Islam needs them here, in Russia.

Their faith, in any case, is not ignited by politics. If it were, the Russian authorities would have cracked down on the mosque long ago. Sarachev came up those steps, on that day four years ago, not out of anger but in search of a way out of the pointlessness of his own life.

Built in the 1990s with Saudi backing, the mosque makes a strong physical statement. Inside, it features intricate woodwork, handsome red and green carpets and painstakingly assembled blue tile mosaics. On holidays, believers pack its services. During afternoon prayers, as they face to the southwest, toward Mecca, a window to their right might give them glimpses of a glorious pearly pink sky, otherworldly almost, even as the setting sun glints off the five golden domes of the Orthodox church across the way.

“I was shocked,” remembers Sarachev. “I couldn’t understand where I was. There were only young people, all around. They treated me so well. I’d never been welcomed like that before.”

He saw familiar faces. Almas Tikhonov, who had been a big partier and a roughneck, and then had dropped from sight, was there, praying. Sarachev was impressed by the way Almas looked; there was a compelling serenity about him.

In the days that followed, that picture lingered in Sarachev’s mind. He decided to go back to the mosque, and then again, and again. He had to endure the jibes of his old friends, and that was hard – but maybe it stiffened his resolve, too. As he began to see them in a new light, it made it simpler to give up the drinking, the hanging out on street corners, the sneaking off to a village where they could party all night, away from parents’ eyes. Sarachev eventually came to understand that the world is full of devils, and that the duty of a good Muslim is to overcome those devils.

And somewhere here, he knows, though he’s still working it through in his own mind, lies the meaning of jihad. “It’s a struggle against those who don’t believe,” he says. “It’s not a test. Jihad is a war.”

Sarachev is a Tatar. His ancestors converted to Islam in the 9th century, when Tatarstan was a powerful state in its own right. For the past 450 years, the Tatars have lived under Russian domination; proud of their heritage, they consider themselves the natural leaders of Russia’s 30 million Muslims.

But Sarachev’s forebears didn’t practice Islam the way he understands it today. Over a millennium, Tatars had developed a rich and complicated theology, comfortable with rational thought and mindful of the need to coexist with the Christian Russians. In Kazan, Tatarstan’s capital, the religious establishment endeavors to carry on that tradition today.

But Soviet hostility to religion left most Tatars with only a perfunctory sense of their own Muslim inheritance. Growing up, Sarachev remembers, religion meant grandparents and holidays, and little else. Yet even then, just after the collapse of the Soviet Union, Arab proselytizers had come to Tatarstan, and they were preaching a different sort of Islam – starker, simpler, more puritanical. It has taken root here, and it appeals powerfully to young people who, like Sarachev, are drawn to its order and rules, and to its purity.

Slow acceptance

Almetyevsk, a city of 150,000 with no history to speak of – it was founded in 1955 – lies among low brown ridges, a four-hour drive east of Kazan. It’s not material poverty here that drives young Tatars to Islam, because oil and gas have brought prosperity, but a spiritual poverty in a country where every institution, from schools to hospitals to the police, is riddled with cynicism and corruption.

Sarachev’s parents divorced when he was young. His mother works at a pipe factory; Sarachev has a job there now, too, operating a hydraulic press. He still lives at his mother’s apartment.

When he embraced Islam he learned that everyone is born with an inner faith, “and it is the parents who turn a person away from religion.” Not necessarily one’s literal parents, he adds; it could be a metaphor for society. But it’s little wonder that his own mother and father were unhappy with his religious awakening and rejection of the culture they lived in.

“They didn’t understand,” he says. “There were fights and quarrels. But of course they had been very mad at me when I was getting home late and drunk.” So when they saw that that stopped, they started, slowly, to come around. Now, he says, if his mother sees him praying at home, she’ll close the door and won’t interfere. (She adamantly refused to be interviewed for this article.)

This year, for the first time, they gave him the money to buy a sacrificial sheep.

Nov. 16 was the day Muslims honored Ibrahim, who intended to slit his son Ismail’s throat but sacrificed a ram instead. After an early-morning service at the mosque, a large crowd moved outdoors to a parking area for buses. Now it was filled with farmers’ trucks, each carrying a dozen or so restless sheep. Under a damp sky, the chief imam, in a gray hat made from fetal lamb’s skin, presided. With him stood the head of the city administration, the veterinary officer, and plainclothes leaders from the security services.

The sheep – more than 600 of them, each hobbled with three feet tied together – were carried to wooden pallets laid out on the ground, where their jugular veins were slashed. Blood flowed down gutters that ran the length of each pallet. At times a butcher would have to sit on an animal for a minute or more after its head was half severed, as it kicked and heaved.

Then the carcasses were skinned and cut into three equal parts: one for the purchaser, one for his relatives, and one for the poor.

“Those who cut a Muslim into three parts are much worse than those who cut a sheep into three parts,” said the imam, Nail bin Ahmad Sakhibzyanov.

Sarachev went home happy, proud in the profession of his faith. The imam went home happy, too. It was the biggest slaughter yet in Almetyevsk.

Striving for faith

Sakhibzyanov, 53, studied to be an imam in what was then Soviet Uzbekistan. He says he dealt with the KGB agents who infiltrated religious schools in those days by telling them what they wanted to hear. What a man says, he suggests, is not necessarily what’s in his heart.

Today, this is what Sakhibzyanov says: that his goal is to help Tatars regain their traditional religion. Yes, he studied in Saudi Arabia in the 1990s, and yes, the school he runs uses a Saudi curriculum. But naturally he subscribes to the Tatars’ traditional Hanafi branch of Islam, he says; if he didn’t, his school would lose its license. He only wants to help the wayward Tatars, buffeted by centuries of Russian and Soviet rule, find their way.

His opponents in Kazan say his Islam is Hanafi in name only, that it otherwise bears the hallmarks of its Arab – or Salafi – origins. They say its focus on Islamic purity is the flip side of intolerance toward other Muslims, and narrow-minded zeal.

“Almetyevsk is the center of Islamic radicalism in Russia,” says Rafik Mukhametshin, rector of the Russian Islamic University in Kazan. “They’re trying to return to a mythical Islam. And they’re unpredictable because they refuse to learn from history.”

Almetyevsk, he says, is the most dangerous spot in Russia.

And yet part of Islam’s appeal for Sarachev was its promise of simple domestic happiness.

“I had a choice,” he says. “Either the street – alcohol and cigarettes and all that stuff – or a very pleasant atmosphere and pleasant people.”

Now, instead of partying, he plays on an all-Muslim rugby team. He drinks coffee instead of vodka, and where once he danced, now he likes to take walks. The job is just a job, but the pay allows him to spend convivial hours at the banya – the Russian sauna.

His new friends at the mosque have married, and they have jobs and kids and cars. Sarachev’s aim is to live the good, respectable life. He sees Islam as the way to achieve it.

That’s not exactly radical. But he knows, uneasily, that there’s more to his Islam than that. Faith is difficult and much is demanded. Islam has powerful enemies, not only the non-believers who wage war on Muslims but also the devil that lives in everyone. Error is widespread, and Sarachev is keen to avoid it, if he can only be sure how.

Sakhibzyanov tells his followers that the struggle is between the soul and the brain – between faith, in other words, and thought. The Muslim must strive for faith.

If that’s true, his detractors argue, it’s no wonder the imam’s Islam has such a strong appeal for those who learned their values on the street, in the with-us-or-against-us world at the margins of society.

But not every young worshiper here has that background. Guzel Sharipova, 23, was everything as a student that Sarachev was not; she studied chemistry on a full scholarship in Kazan, and graduated with highest honors. It was in Kazan that Islam found her, thanks to an Arab boyfriend. She was living with her great-aunt, Galima Abdullina, a retired schoolteacher, and began asking her about the prayers she recited. Eventually, she put on a veil.

“She was a girl who loved life, and suddenly she became so religious,” says Enzhe Anisimova, Abdullina’s daughter. “We watched her as a baby, and she was so beautiful, and spreading light. Now she’s so serious. Islam is very close to me, but that doesn’t mean that I accept everything. Something in it really attracts Guzel. But what is it? If she has found answers to the questions she was trying to find answers to, maybe that solved something for her.”

Sharipova says, “Everyone has a time to come to Islam.” She draws deep satisfaction from the rules it imposes. That frees up so much. She works now as a chemist – with her brain – but she gives her attention to her soul.

And where Sarachev hopes Islam will bring him modest comforts, Sharipova treasures the way it allows her to discard life’s vanities. “I’m trying to spend time on only necessary things,” she says.

New expectations

Rustam Sarachev came to the mosque knowing almost nothing about Islam. Now he knows that praying to ancestors, or saints, is the worst imaginable sin. He knows that being Muslim is more important than being a Tatar. He knows that the Russian special services don’t like Islam because the alcohol and tobacco Muslims reject are big businesses. He knows those same special services dread the day when all people turn to Islam.

His ancestors, in centuries past, drank beer and mead at weddings and often sought the intercession of their forebears in prayer. Would Sarachev consider them Muslims if he met them today – or devils? In his earnest way, he’s only beginning to deal with the difficult questions. He’s happy that Islam is helping him find the answers.

“Everyone eventually asks, ‘Why am I here? Why will I die? What will happen after I die?’ You gradually start to understand who you are and why you were created.”

It is, he says, to live a pure Muslim’s life. And, through Islam, all is spelled out. “The prophet showed people everything – from how to go to the toilet to how to run a state.” But there’s still so much to get straight in his own mind.

Last year, Sarachev got to know some young men who wanted to pick up guns and go fight abroad. They weren’t from the mosque. He thinks they had taught themselves Islam on the Internet. Sometimes, when they met on the street, they’d start urging him to go off and fight against Americans.

He says he was troubled by it, and as he describes it he still looks troubled by it. He’s struggling to understand even now what’s expected of him by his religion. He went to the mosque and asked the imams for advice.

They explained to him, he says, that these young men were mistaken. “Those people who say they want to fight, they’re like foam on water. There’s a lot of foam, but it’s useless.”

Eventually they went away, he doesn’t know where. Sarachev, yearning to dig deeper into Islam, is still uncertain about jihad, and the fight against devils. “It’s very complicated. I don’t want to be wrong.”

Sakhibzyanov knew about the would-be fighters. All Muslims, he says, know they are part of a larger community that must defend itself. But leaving Tatarstan to fight elsewhere is, he says, the wrong choice. “They are needed here.”

The imam is a savvy navigator in a potentially hostile culture. Islam, he says, is a peaceful religion, violence is a sin and the task for Rustam Sarachev and other young Muslims is to keep studying and deepening their certainty in its purity and oneness. And then more will follow, and then more.


Indian opposition to hold anti-corruption protests

December 22, 2010

India’s main opposition alliance is due to hold a major demonstration against alleged corruption involving the ruling Congress-party led government.


India has seen a slew of high-profile corruption investigations in recent months

The Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party-led group plans to hold anti-sleaze protests in Delhi and across the country.

India has been rocked by a slew of high-profile corruption cases.

Among them is an alleged telecoms scandal in which phone licences were sold for a fraction of their value.

Ex-telecoms minister Andimuthu Raja, who resigned over the scandal, is expected to be questioned soon by India’s top investigation agency, the CBI.

Mr Raja, who denies any wrongdoing, is a member of the DMK party, a member of the Congress-led ruling coalition.

Parliament has been deadlocked over opposition demands for a major inquiry.

Correspondents say that the main opposition Hindu nationalist BJP-led alliance has decided to take to the streets to pin down the government over corruption.

‘Nothing to hide’

The opposition protest comes days after Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said he has “nothing to hide” from an investigation into the sale of phone licences.

He told a party meeting he was ready to be questioned by a parliamentary panel in the inquiry.

Congress party chief Sonia Gandhi told the same meeting that graft was a “disease spreading through our society”.

The CBI raided Mr Raja’s premises this month and is expected to question him about claims he issued 2G licences on a first-come, first-served basis instead of auctioning them.

The national auditor said the 2008 sale cost the government up to $37bn (£23bn) in lost revenue.

The other corruption investigations in recent months involve financial malpractices at October’s Commonwealth Games and an alleged housing scam.

Organisers of the Delhi Commonwealth Games have been arrested on charges of swindling millions of dollars before the October event.

The Congress party ordered the chief minister of the western state of Maharashtra to quit over his alleged role in a scam involving homes meant for war widows being given to relatives and bureaucrats.


AT EASE WITH GREASE – Indian Army

November 15, 2010

General Deepak Kapoor may seem like a terrible aberration. But BRIJESH PANDEY finds the rot runs deeper in the army


Caught in action When he was army chief, Gen Kapoor opened his office to wheeler dealers

AS THE saga of General (retd) Deepak Kapoor and Company unfolds, the nation is traumatised by the crumbling of a pillar it still believes in, by and large. Can the country still bank on this institution to keep the borders safe as well as rush in to save the day when there is a natural calamity or civil strife? Does the rot go deep or is it confined to a few aberrations?

It was in 2001 that TEHELKA’s seminal exposé on corruption in defence procurement – ‘Operation Westend’ – graphically laid bare the dangerous spread of the cancer of corruption in the higher ranks of the Indian Army. But instead of launching a no-holds barred clean-up act, the establishment and the army encouraged a witch-hunt against TEHELKA. The then NDA government used the State machinery to hit back. The gunfire was clearly misdirected, for it created an enabling environment for corruption to grow, as seen in the indictment of senior officers in corruption cases in the past five years. An opportunity to put the house in order was wasted.

As the decade closes, there is now a darker cloud over the army. But there is also a silver lining made up of several strands: that whistles were blown, that other officers went by the book trying to expose embezzlements, that Courts of Inquiry (CoI) scrupulously did their job, that court martials were proposed. And now, hopefully, thanks to the unsparing glare of media exposure, the establishment will fight to regain the stature and pride of place it enjoyed until a decade ago.

OFFICERS, NOT GENTLEMEN
The turn of the millennium has seen many scams blight the army’s image

There’s a compelling reason why the defence establishment – which includes politicians, bureaucrats and military bureaucrats – needs to stop the tide of corruption. By 2015, India would have spent Rs. 2.21 lakh crore on what consultancy firm KPMG terms “one of the largest procurement cycles in the world”. Leading global defence manufacturers are flocking to Delhi for a slice of our defence spending. Indian firms too stand to gain contracts worth Rs. 44,299 crore. The scope for kickbacks and grease money are obvious.

Three months ago, Patrick Choy, chief marketing officer of Singapore-based defence firm ST Kinetics, blurted out what is known as the emerging truth for foreign defence firms operating in India: “It’s come to a point where I wonder about ST Kinetics being driven out of the Indian market by frustration. We cannot simply continue with something that appears like a black hole.” His firm, reportedly blacklisted during Kapoor’s tenure, was in competition with BAE Systems for the Rs. 13,289 crore 155-mm gun contract.

Kapoor has become an object of hatred for armymen and women, serving and retired, with good reason: it is said that he didn’t just pocket a few kickbacks, he allegedly invited the entire evil axis of corruption – politician-contractor-police-bureaucrat – into the office of the army chief. He did this by letting it be known within political circles that he is pliable and ready to use his office to share the spoils. Some officers blame his predecessor General NC Vij for starting the slide.

A PART FROM the scope for making money under the table in equipment purchases, there is immense opportunity in the prime land owned by the armed forces, which is coveted by real estate sharks backed by politicians. This is where the defence establishment could stand firm, or succumb to the neta-broker combine. Other officers are outraged. “It hurts like hell,” says Maj Gen (retd) GD Bakshi, when asked about the Adarsh scam. In fact, when the Maharashtra government gave the building the operational certificate, Western Naval Commander Vice Admiral Sanjeev Bhasin wrote that the skyscraper poses a security threat to the nearby naval base and sought action against the promoters and officers involved since 2003.


PHOTO: AFP , DEEPAK SALVI

Kapoor and Vij feigning ignorance about the fact that this society was meant to house Kargil war widows did not cut much ice with their own fraternity. “A senior officer saying he didn’t know that the flats were meant for war widows? What nonsense. Then they are unfit to hold that rank,” says Major General (retd) SCN Jatar.

His scepticism is borne out by facts. When Kapoor applied for the Adarsh flat in 2005, the membership rules were clear: an aspirant should have lived in Mumbai for 15 years. To get this waived, he wrote to then CM Vilasrao Deshmukh, who obliged him with a domicile certificate. His salary slip submitted with the application showed an income of only Rs. 23,450 per month. When his attention was drawn to the fake slip, he expressed surprise.

Equally damningly, Trinamool Congress MP Ambika Banerjee, in a letter dated 5 August, had written to the defence minister that Kapoor had assets disproportionate to his known sources of income. “There’s a flat in Dwarka Sector 29, three flats in Gurgaon Sector 23, one flat in Gurgaon Sector 42/44, a flat in Gurgaon Phase III and a house in Lokhandwala in Mumbai,” she revealed in her letter. Kapoor had met Defence Minister AK Antony to deny this allegation.

The shock of all these skeletons tumbling out is so profound that former army chief VP Malik says, “Nothing has hurt the army as much as this latest scam as far as corruption is concerned.”

But the trail goes all the way back to the Sukhna land scam in which Kapoor was perceived as going soft on Lieutenant General Awdhesh Prakash, his military secretary. To recall the story: a private educational institution, Geetanjali Educational Trust, was allowed to purchase 70 acres near the 33 Corps in Sukhna. Investigations revealed the involvement of several top officers, including Lt Gen Rath, Lt Gen Halgali and Prakash. How serious was the damage can be gauged from the fact that Rath was all set to take over as deputy army chief and Prakash was one of the eight military advisors to the army chief with the most enviable charge – promotions and postings. General VK Singh, the current army chief, was then GOC-in-C of the Eastern Command and headed the COI constituted to probe charges against all four. The COI found them guilty and it recommended that Prakash be sacked. However, Kapoor stepped in and recommended that only administrative action should be taken against him. This caused so much commotion that Antony had to write a letter to the army chief asking for a court martial.

That’s not all. In 2006, Maj Gen Malhotra of the Ordnance Corps floated a proposal for purchase of tents worth Rs. 16 crore. It was said in the proposal that there was an extreme shortage of tents and they should be purchased using the special financial powers of the Area Commander. The file then went to Major General General Staff (MGGS) of the Northern Command, who wrote on the file, “Are we going to spend the army’s special financial power for buying tents which are supposed to be supplied by Ordnance?” What was surprising was that three months after that rejection, Malhotra again moved a proposal recalling that he had proposed the purchase three months ago and said that the troops are suffering because of tent shortage. This time, the MGGS signed the file without a murmur. Kapoor also gave his nod.

By 2015, India would have spent Rs. 2.21 lakh crore on ‘one of the largest procurement cycles in the world’

After that, Kapoor moved over to army headquarters as vice-chief. On the day Lt Gen HS Panag took over as commander, he found an anonymous note apprising him of the tent scam. On investigation, it was found that tents were not even needed. A COI under Maj Gen Sapru found that Malhotra was guilty of siphoning off Rs. 1.6 crore. Panag issued an order that would stop Malhotra’s future promotions.

Panag had no idea that he had stirred a hornet’s nest – Kapoor had by that time become army chief, and ordered Panag’s transfer to the Central Command in the middle of his two-year tenure. Panag met Kapoor but was curtly told that transfers were his prerogative. Panag also met Antony. “It was clear that Kapoor was rattled but then, between an army chief and an army commander, Antony chose the chief,” a retired officer said on the condition of anonymity.

This incident is cause for much heartburn in the army, as it is unusual that an army commander is moved in the middle of his tenure. Further blows were dealt to the defence establishment when the Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) report on defence services for the year ended March 2007 tabled in Parliament indicted the then Northern Command chief for misusing powers delegated to him for special operational requirements.

TEHELKA CONTACTED Kapoor several times to get his version. On the fifth call, he refused to rebut the charges against him. “There are a lot of things going on and I would not like to comment,” he says.

What a mighty fall this has been for a respected institution can be gauged from the fact that till 2002-03, the thought of court martialling an officer of the rank of major general was considered to be a rarity. In 2010, names of former chiefs are figuring in scams. The fall has been precipitate. Apart from these headline-grabbing scams of the past five years, there are others in almost every department of the army. Be it Supply Corps or Ordnance, top officers were busy siphoning off money. :

  • In 2006, a COI found Maj Gen Gur Iqbal Singh Multani, four brigadiers and seven other officers guilty of sale of military quota liquor in the open market.
  • In 2006, Lt Gen Surendra K Sahni, a major general, two brigadiers and eight other officers were found guilty of massive irregularities in procurement of ‘certain items of dry rations’ for soldiers in Jammu & Kashmir.
  • In 2007, a COI indicted Lt Gen SK Dahiya Brigadier DVS Vishnoi and three other officers for alleged irregularities in the operation of the ‘frozen meat contract’ for supplies to troops posted in the highaltitude Ladakh sector.
  • In 2009, 41 officers were found guilty of selling their ‘non-service pattern’ weapons for personal use in the grey market.

So, what made these senior officers shift from first gear to fourth in such a short span, when it came to corruption?

According to Maj Gen (retd) Afsar Kareem, “These kind of things happen when the top leadership is weak and corrupt. The culture is that everybody looks up. If the man on the top is clean, nobody down the ranks dare do anything. But if the chap at the top looks the other way or himself is involved, or his honesty is not fully established, he fails in every respect, be it war or peace he is not fit for the army. But by then, because they help each other, they get promotions, they get decorations and this develops a nexus if left unchecked.”

Most senior army people agree that a general doesn’t become corrupt only when he attains that rank. The question that logically arises then is: How does a guy who is corrupt rise to that level?

At fault is a promotion policy based on the whims and fancies of the top echelons of the military and politicians. “If you are clever and you are dishonest then you have a better chance of promotion than being honest and professionally competent, unless the people at the top recognise that and unless the government plays a part,” says Kareem. “The government generally likes to put an yes-man in that position. And the man who has much to hide is always a yes-man.”

Maj Gen AK Kapur had a net worth of Rs. 41,000 when he joined the army in 1971. By 2007, his net was Rs. 5.5 crore

A senior officer confirmed TEHELKA’s suspicion that the Adarsh and Sukhna land scam are merely tips of the iceberg. “The real scam happens in the procurement department,” he said. “First there is the Army Supply Corps. We have 13 lakh soldiers. Now if we spend Rs. 50 per day on one soldier’s food, the daily budget would be Rs. 6.5 crore. Imagine the kind of money involved and the potential for siphoning it off.”

Then there is Ordnance, which supplies everything, from socks to weapons. Its annual budget is Rs. 8,000-10,000 crore. Tellingly, throughout 2009 the corps had no chief as the three eligible officers were facing graft charges. Maj Gen AK Kapur (according to the chargesheet), had a net worth of Rs. 41,000 when he joined the army in 1971. By 2007, his assets had grown to Rs. 5.5 crore. He owns 13 properties in Delhi, Gurgaon, Shimla and Goa.

Maj Gen Anil Swarup, who was officiating commandant of the College of Materials Management, Jabalpur, has also been found guilty of irregularities in the purchase of items for a unit headed on a UN peacekeeping mission. He inflated prices, CWG style – 100-KVA generators available in the market for Rs. 7 lakh were bought for Rs. 15 lakh, cables sold for Rs. 300 were got for Rs. 2,000. The same firm that supplied shoes to a Delhi school for Rs. 700 supplied to the army for Rs. 1,200. This Rs. 100- crore loot continued from 2006 to 2008.

After Supply and Ordnance comes the Military Engineering Service, which also works for the navy and air force. Its annual construction budget is at least 10,000- 12,000 crore, with buildings and airstrips perpetually under construction. In this, 10 percent commission is regarded as ‘legitimate’. All of these scams require a nexus with defence and finance ministry staff.

IF THIS brazen corruption continues, soldier morale and consequently the security of the country comes under threat. “It erodes the command and control chain. After all, military leadership is inspirational,” says Maj Gen GD Bakshi. “I can’t tell a soldier: I will give you a Rs. 5,000 bonus, please go and die. But he goes and dies for a Rs. 5,000 salary because it is for the honour of his country, his unit.”

A senior officer adds: “Below the rank of colonel, there is no corruption – if you leave aside procurement department or minor incidents. As people get independent, get more power, they start alignments with their bosses and this is when they are moulded as one of the corrupt lot. They don’t sign the main contract but remain in the shadow of their bosses.”

Several officers believe that this rot can be stemmed in time if the army makes an example of those indicted, as it was in the Sukhna land scam. According to Maj Gen Jatar, “In my opinion they should have been stripped of rank. They have no business to be called generals and retired chiefs of the army or navy. Lower ranks must see that even former chiefs are not spared.”

To get rid of the plague, serving and retired army personnel agree that it’s time for extreme action. You have to sacrifice a limb in order to save the body – otherwise, watch one of the most magnificent institutions crumble before your eyes.

brijesh@tehelka.com


Delhi University girl gangraped; one arrested

November 11, 2010

CNN-IBN

New Delhi: In yet another incident that raises questions on the safety of women in the national capital, a 19-year-old call center employee was allegedly gangraped by an autorickshaw driver and his friends.

What is shocking is that the vicitm was held captive for 12 hours. The main accused has been arrested and the police is on the look out for others

The main accused — 22 year-old Ramvir — has been arrested for allegedly kidnapping and raping the 19 year-old in East Delhi.

The incident took place at 5 am on the morning of Nov 3. The victim, who is also a student of Delhi University, was on her way to her pick-up point when a group of men in an autorickshaw pulled her inside the auto.

“They took me to a desolate location and gangraped me. They even threatened to kill me if I didn’t come whenever they asked me to,” the victim said.

The victim says she was held captive for almost twelve hours by the accused. The police is now on the lookout for the other three accused who are missing.

Meanwhile, the victim’s mother has alleged that the police refused to cooperate with her in filing the case.

“They took almost four hours to file an FIR,” the victim’s mother told CNN-IBN.

The victim’s mother was also instrumental in nabbing the accused. After the police failed to arrest the culprit, she called Ramvir, posing as the victim, to a city hospital from where he was arrested.

Incidentally, the arrest came on the day when the new Delhi Police Commissioner stressed on the need for police officers to be more sensitive towards women and juveniles.


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 81 other followers